Are You Getting Your Generator Size Wrong?

Are You Getting Your Generator Size Wrong? The Hidden Costs of Guesswork

A power outage strikes. Lights flicker and die. The refrigerator hums to a stop. The silence is unnerving. If you have a generator, this is the moment you count on it to kick in and restore some semblance of normalcy. But what if it doesn’t? Or what if it struggles, trips breakers, or can only power a fraction of what you need?

The culprit might not be the generator itself, but its size. Choosing the wrong size generator is a remarkably common mistake, and one that can lead to frustrating inefficiencies, wasted money, and even potential damage to your generator and connected appliances. This article delves into why getting the size right is crucial and how you can avoid falling into the generator sizing trap.

The Pitfalls of Incorrect Sizing

When it comes to generators, size definitely matters. Unlike buying a slightly-too-big coat that you can grow into, an incorrectly sized generator presents immediate and ongoing problems.

Too Small: The Underdog That Can’t Cope

Purchasing a generator that’s too small for your needs is perhaps the most common error. It’s often driven by a desire to save money upfront, as smaller units are typically less expensive. However, the consequences quickly outweigh any initial savings:

1. Overload and Tripping Breakers: Your generator has a maximum power output (rated in watts). If the combined power demand of the appliances and lights you plug in exceeds this capacity, the generator’s built-in breaker will trip, shutting down power to everything. You’ll be constantly juggling which essential items can run simultaneously.
2. Failure to Start High-Draw Appliances: Many appliances with motors (refrigerators, air conditioners, pumps, furnaces) require a significant surge of power to start up – often several times their normal running wattage. A generator that’s too small simply won’t be able to provide this initial jolt, meaning these critical items won’t start at all.
3. Strain and Potential Damage: Constantly operating a generator at or near its absolute maximum capacity puts immense strain on the engine and alternator. This can lead to overheating, premature wear and tear, reduced lifespan, and increased maintenance costs.
4. Unstable Power: An overloaded generator may struggle to maintain a stable voltage and frequency output. While some electronics are resilient, sensitive devices like computers, modern TVs, and certain medical equipment can potentially be damaged by "dirty power."
5. Lack of Preparedness: Ultimately, the biggest pitfall is that the generator fails to provide the level of backup power you thought you were buying. You’re still left in a difficult situation during an extended outage.

Too Large: The Oversized Underperformer

While less common than buying too small, purchasing a generator that’s significantly larger than you need also comes with its own set of drawbacks:

1. Wasted Money: Larger generators cost more to buy, install (especially standby units), and maintain. You’re paying for capacity you simply don’t use.
2. Inefficiency and Higher Fuel Consumption: Generators are generally most fuel-efficient when operating at a certain percentage of their capacity (often between 50% and 75%). An oversized generator running a small load will consume more fuel per kilowatt-hour produced than a properly sized unit.
3. "Wet Stacking" (Primarily Diesel): This is a serious issue, particularly for diesel generators. When a diesel engine runs for extended periods on a very light load, it doesn’t reach optimal operating temperature. Unburned fuel, carbon deposits, and moisture can accumulate in the exhaust system, leading to a condition called "wet stacking." This reduces performance, can damage the engine, and requires costly servicing to clear.
4. Increased Noise and Footprint: Larger generators are typically noisier and take up more space than their smaller counterparts.
5. Higher Maintenance Costs: Parts and service for larger units are generally more expensive.

Understanding the Power Needs: Running Watts vs. Starting Watts

To size a generator correctly, you need to understand the two key power ratings for electrical devices:

1. Running Watts (or Rated Watts): This is the continuous power an appliance needs to operate normally once it’s running. Think of it as the power required to keep the lights on, the refrigerator cold, or the fan spinning. This is the number you’ll see on appliance labels under "WATTS" during normal operation.
2. Starting Watts (or Surge Watts): This is the extra burst of power required for a fraction of a second to get an electric motor or compressor started. Devices like refrigerators, freezers, air conditioners, well pumps, furnaces, and power tools often have starting watt requirements that are 2 to 3 times (sometimes even more) their running watts. Once the motor starts, the power demand drops back down to the running wattage.

A generator must be capable of handling the sum of the running watts of all the appliances you want to run simultaneously, plus the highest single starting watt requirement among those appliances at the moment it starts.

How to Size Your Generator Correctly: A Step-by-Step Guide

Accurate generator sizing is essentially an exercise in calculating your power needs. Here’s how to do it:

1. Identify Your Essential Items: During a power outage, what absolutely must run? Make a list. This might include:

   • Refrigerator/Freezer
   • Furnace (blower motor and controls)
   • Well Pump (if applicable)
   • Lights (specify how many and what type – LED, incandescent)
   • Fans (ceiling or portable)
   • Medical equipment (CPAP, oxygen concentrator – critical!)
   • sump pump
   • Critical electronics (computer, Wi-Fi router)
   • Maybe a TV or microwave for comfort

2. Find the Wattage for Each Item:

   • Look for a label on the appliance itself. It might list "WATTS," "AMPS," and "VOLTS." If it gives amps and volts, you can calculate watts using the formula: Watts = Volts x Amps. For example, a 120V appliance drawing 5 amps needs 600 watts (120 x 5).
   • Check the owner’s manual or the manufacturer’s website.
   • If you can’t find specific numbers, use a general wattage chart as a starting point (many are available online), but be aware these are estimates.

3. Create Your Wattage List: Draw two columns: "Running Watts" and "Starting Watts." List each essential item and its corresponding wattage.

   • Example Entry:

     • Refrigerator | 800 Watts (Running) | 2400 Watts (Starting)
     • Furnace Blower | 600 Watts (Running) | 1800 Watts (Starting)
     • Several LED Lights | 100 Watts (Running) | 0 Watts (Starting – lights usually don’t have a significant start surge)
     • Well Pump | 1000 Watts (Running) | 3000 Watts (Starting)
     • Microwave | 1500 Watts (Running) | 0 Watts (Starting – resistive load)

4. Calculate Total Running Watts: Add up all the running wattage requirements from your list. This is the continuous power your generator needs to supply when everything on your list is running at the same time.

   • Example Calculation: 800 (Fridge) + 600 (Furnace) + 100 (Lights) + 1000 (Pump) + 1500 (Microwave) = 4000 Total Running Watts

5. Identify the Peak Starting Watt Requirement: Look at the "Starting Watts" column. Find the single highest starting wattage requirement among all the items you listed. You don’t add these together, because typically only one motor-driven appliance will start at any given moment (e.g., the fridge or the well pump, but not usually both at the exact same second).

   • Example Identification: Comparing 2400 (Fridge), 1800 (Furnace), 0 (Lights), 3000 (Pump), 0 (Microwave), the highest is 3000 Watts (Well Pump).

6. Determine Required Generator Capacity: Your generator needs to have a Running Watt capacity that meets or exceeds your "Total Running Watts" calculation (Step 4) AND a Starting Watt (Surge Watt) capacity that meets or exceeds your "Peak Starting Watt Requirement" (Step 5).

   • Example Requirement: Need a generator with at least 4000 Running Watts and at least 3000 Starting Watts above the running load when that specific item starts. More accurately: The generator’s peak Starting Watt rating must be at least the total running watts (4000) PLUS the highest single starting wattage requirement (3000), resulting in a minimum peak rating of 7000 Watts (4000 + 3000).

7. Add a Safety Margin: It’s wise to add a safety margin of 20-25% to your required running wattage. This accounts for any minor errors in calculation, future needs, and ensures the generator isn’t constantly maxed out, which improves performance and lifespan.

   • Example Calculation with Margin: Required Running Watts = 4000. Add 25% margin: 4000 * 1.25 = 5000 Watts.
   • Your final requirement in this example would be a generator with a Running Watt rating of at least 5000 Watts and a Starting Watt rating of at least 7000 Watts.

Other Factors to Consider Beyond Watts

While wattage is paramount, don’t forget other important factors when choosing a generator:

• Fuel Type: Gasoline, propane, diesel, or natural gas? Consider availability, storage, and efficiency.
• Portability vs. Standby: Do you need a portable unit you can move or a permanently installed standby generator with an automatic transfer switch?
• Noise Level: Generators can be noisy. Check the decibel rating and consider placement relative to your home and neighbours.
• Connection: How will the generator connect to your home’s electrical system? For anything beyond plugging in individual appliances, a transfer switch installed by a qualified electrician is essential for safety and compliance.

When in Doubt, Consult a Professional

If your power needs are complex (e.g., large home, multiple AC units, medical equipment) or you’re considering a whole-house standby system, it is highly recommended to consult a qualified electrician. They can perform a detailed load calculation, assess your home’s electrical system, and ensure the generator is properly sized, installed, and connected safely and according to code.

---

FAQs: Your Generator Sizing Questions Answered

• Q: What’s the difference between Running Watts and Starting Watts?

  • A: Running watts are the continuous power needed to keep an appliance operating. Starting watts are the temporary surge of power required to start a motor-driven appliance (like a refrigerator or pump). The starting watts are typically much higher than the running watts for these items.

• Q: Can’t I just buy a really big generator to be safe?

  • A: While buying slightly oversized is better than too small, significantly oversizing wastes money (higher purchase price, fuel, maintenance) and can lead to inefficient operation and potential issues like "wet stacking" in diesel models if running light loads for long periods.

• Q: What happens if I accidentally overload my generator?

  • A: Most generators have a built-in circuit breaker designed to trip and shut down power if the load exceeds the generator’s capacity. This protects the generator from damage. However, repeatedly tripping the breaker isn’t good for the unit.

• Q: How do I find the wattage of my appliances?

  • A: Look for a label directly on the appliance, check the owner’s manual, or search online using the make and model number. Sometimes, the label lists amps and volts instead; use the formula Watts = Volts x Amps.

• Q: Do I need a transfer switch?

  • A: For portable generators powering essential circuits, a manual transfer switch is crucial for safety. It isolates your home’s electrical system from the utility grid, preventing power from backfeeding onto utility lines (which is extremely dangerous for utility workers) and preventing the generator from being damaged when utility power is restored. Standby generators always connect via an automatic transfer switch. Plugging appliances directly into the generator outlets or using extension cords is okay for a few items, but for connecting to your home’s wiring, a transfer switch is mandatory for safety and code compliance.

• Q: My generator is rated in kVA, not Watts. How do I convert?

  • A: kVA (kilovolt-amps) is "apparent power," while kW (kilowatts) is "real power" (watts). The conversion involves a "power factor," typically around 0.8 for most generators. So, kW = kVA x Power Factor. If a generator is 10 kVA with a 0.8 power factor, its wattage is roughly 8 kW, or 8000 Watts. Always check the generator’s specifications for its actual kW rating if available.

---

Conclusion: Powering On with Confidence

Investing in a generator is an investment in peace of mind during power outages. But that investment is only sound if the generator is correctly sized for your specific needs. Getting the size wrong, whether too small or too large, leads to frustration, inefficiency, potential damage, and ultimately, a failure to deliver the reliable backup power you expect.

By taking the time to carefully calculate your essential power requirements – understanding the difference between running and starting watts – and considering other crucial factors, you can select a generator that will perform reliably for years to come. Don’t guess; assess. Your preparedness (and your appliances) will thank you. And remember, for complex situations or whole-house systems, professional help is always a smart investment.